Rethinking representativeness: when a deliberate imbalance builds legitimacy

Anthony Kevins and Joshua Robison released a paper in June 2026 discussing the role of sortition in climate assemblies. They consider a commonly overlooked factor: how the public react to climate assemblies and DMPs partaking in targeted recruitment where those directly affected by the issue are involved in the process.

They found that targeted recruitment increases public support for climate assemblies and has the possibility of increasing its legitimacy. Deviations from representativeness may be received positively by the public as long as it appears useful. They also find that the support for targeted assemblies does not depend on how the public feels toward the targeted group but note that this can’t be ruled out in the case of highly polarising groups. Finally, they note that follow up analyses only found weak evidence for understanding if targeting made people think more about humanitarian concerns or changed what they expected the assembly to recommend.